Lost Isn’t Over Yet, But It’s Time To Leave The Island

It’s time for Americans to get off their island” says one Fulbright recipient, explaining why it’s important for US citizens to spend time in other countries, especially given what seems to be a common negative impression of the US.

First of all, one of the reasons I think it is so valuable to teach EFL even for a year or two is just this: it gives you the chance to live in another country and actually interact with locals on a personal level.

However I’m not okay with the idea that Americans - or anyone - should travel or work abroad with the goal of “representing” their country. There is definitely something to be said for positive interactions between those from different countries…but people don’t need to be defined on the basis of their citizenship (or language or religion or hair color) or assumed to represent others because of it. In many contexts we talk about making judgments on a whole group of people based on the actions of one or two as a bad thing…is this really different from treating people as “representatives” of their country?

I think one positive result of spending time abroad is realizing that people are not fundamentally different because they come from different countries. I’d also say: instead of framing time abroad as a chance to promote your own country’s image – frame it as an opportunity for you to learn about your host country because that has value in itself.


By Katie | Permalink

Related Posts



Subscribe
 

rss icon TEFL RSS Feed

Print
Print this article
Share

del.icio.us:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island digg:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island spurl:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island wists:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island simpy:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island newsvine:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island
 blinklist:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island furl:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island reddit:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island fark:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island blogmarks:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island Y!:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island
 smarking:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island stumbleupon:Lost Isn't Over Yet, But It's Time To Leave The Island Add this page to Mister Wong

Comments

Cairogal | August 15th, 2007 at 7:23 pm
top comment

I think many teachers abroad are representatives of their country, whether it’s willing or otherwise. Living in the Middle East, taxi drivers and shop owners would regularly want to engage in a US political discussion. I think many people, despite completely disagreeing with US foreign policy, want to see if we are or are not representative of our government’s political actions. Though we might not walk away from the dialogue in agreement, we do often walk away realising that people are people, and politics are politics. Though I never set off intending to be a representative of all Americans, I don’t doubt I’ve been judged as such.

Peter | August 16th, 2007 at 7:38 am
top comment

I tend to agree with the previous comment. Whilst I would never claim to represent Britain or British people when I’m abroad, I also understand that what I say or do can often have a big impact on the way people perceive Britain. This can be especially true if they haven’t met many British people before. I’m not saying I change the way I act when I’m abroad because of this, just that I’m aware of it.

On a side note, I think a lot of young Americans miss out on spending time abroad because the U.S. is not part of the Working Holiday Visa scheme. Almost every other country in the Western world is part of it and it gives young people a great opportunity to go and spend some time travelling, working and learning a bit more about other countries (albeit exclusively Western ones).

Katie | August 16th, 2007 at 4:55 pm
top comment

Thanks for the comments, Cairogal and Peter. I think you’re both right - it does happen that people are considered something like representatives of their countries…I just think it would be great if it happened less and not more.

I guess my problem is with the idea that that “representing” itself is a reason to go. And I think the sentiment behind that view (”let’s show everyone how great we are”) actually plays a role in some people’s negative image of the US.

Certainly people should be aware that for better or worse they may be seen as some kind of representative - I just don’t like the idea of promoting that type of view.

Katie | August 16th, 2007 at 4:56 pm
top comment

Oh! And good point on the WHV…I think there are few short ones for recent US graduates, like BUNAC, but that WHV is a good deal. I hadn’t really considered that as a reason for why more young people in the US don’t go abroad, but that could be one of the reasons.

Cairogal | August 18th, 2007 at 5:05 pm
top comment

In my mind, the ideal expat the ventures abroad is more interested in learning about other cultures than representing his/her own. It’s those travellers (not tourists) who have the potential to indirectly create a positive experience between Americans and Eritreans or Britons and Koreans, rather than a positive image of Americans or Britons.

TEFL Courses Worldwide

TEFL News

TEFL Forum


 
 
© BootsnAll Travel Network - All rights reserved